Showing posts with label professional development. Show all posts
Showing posts with label professional development. Show all posts

Thursday, March 6, 2025

Conferences and workshops: How should I spend my time and money?

I love language teacher conferences and training. I mean, I REALLY love them. And with that love comes some critical reflection on who they serve, and hopefully some solid ideas for how to spend your very precious time and money. 

I also need to say that as someone who organizes workshops and trainings, I am totally going to reveal my biases - and give myself a shoutout when appropriate. Because it *is* my blog! 

I want to discuss the different types of acquisition- driven conferences (aka comprehension-based, comprehensible input) that I know about, their pros and cons, and give some suggestions for which kind of training / conference is best suited to you, your experience, your teaching context, and your individual needs as a teacher-learner engaging in professional development. 

I am not going to talk about world language conferences that are not specifically acquisition driven (e.g. regional conferences such as SWCOLT, state conferences, or ACTFL). I am also not going to address virtual trainings (such as The Comprehensible Classroom's Acquisition Boot Camps and Micro-Courses, or Mike Peto's CI Master Class) or ongoing professional development such as La Familia Loca PLC, Au Salon des profs, or the Growing with Proficiency Academy. I am just going to focus on workshops and conferences. 

Any errors and all opinions are my own! 

Definitions:

Workshop- usually 1-3 days, led by one speaker or organization, usually with one lead trainer who guides the learning.

Conference- 1-5 days, produced by an organization (profit or non-profit), with sessions presented by different teachers. Some conference models, especially those focused on acquisition-driven instruction, have different tracks for teachers based on their experience with acquisition-driven instruction. 

Let's break this down into more specific categories: 



The Expert-Led Workshop

Examples: Teach and Assess for Acquisition from The Comprehensible Classroom, Acquisition Academy from The Comprehensible Classroom (not offered in 2025),  In-person training from Mike Peto, Annabelle Williamson, Jan Kittok, or Bryce Hedstrom. (Some virtual trainings fall into this as well, e.g. Liam Printer's workshops.) 

This type of workshop usually has only one main speaker. (If it's Acquisition Academy, you get two main speakers!) It is often only one day (unless it is one of mine!), and it is *usually* built to meet the needs of the maximum number of people. 

There are many, many pros to this kind of workshop, especially if you are interested in experiencing learning in a sequenced, planned way with one person's overall idea of what acquisition-driven instruction looks like.  If you are new to acquisition-driven instruction, I think this might be the best use of your money because the folks who provide these workshops work really hard to make them meaningful and applicable. 

Usually there will be some kind of language experience through demonstrations (often in less commonly taught languages- Japanese, Mandarin, Russian, etc.), and maybe opportunities to practice or observe in a skills lab. 

The really adept workshop designers are able to present material that works for those who are brand new and those who have been to a ton of trainings- they create subtly differentiated content that can be accessed by a variety of experience levels. 

Another pro of this kind of workshop is that no matter how experienced you are, it is *always* helpful to review the basics of acquisition driven instruction, and be a learner in another language. Always.   

My Teach and Assess for Acquisition workshops are this kind of workshop, as is the Acquisition Academy that we run. I carefully design every moment, leave nothing to chance, and spend a lot of time thinking about how to sequence each learning experience to maximize impact and minimize overwhelm. And I usually include skills labs somewhere too, because I think they are SO important. 

Pros: 

    • Sequenced learning designed with specific outcomes.
    • Highly experienced presenters
    • Less chance of overwhelm because the presenter is sharing one single vision / approach based on their principles of acquisition and instruction. 
    • You might have the opportunity to work in small groups in a "skills lab" with an experienced coach to practice what you have learned. 
    • Being a student in another language 

Cons: 

    • You might think that you don't need "the basics" any more. (Tip: you might be wrong about that!) 
    • One single track- experienced and brand new grouped all together. This can be frustrating if you are already knowledgable because participant questions will likely be focused on entry level ideas rather than fine tuning your practice. 
    • You may or may not jive with that one person. If you don't, the training will be long. 

"Tracked" Acquisition Driven Conference

Examples: The CI Summit. Examples from history: IFLT, Fluency Matters Conference, NTPRS

This type of conference is a bit of a hybrid. It will include many elements of a an expert led workshop, such as opportunities to be a language learner in a new-to-you language, and a sequenced learning path that will be different for each level of experience. Usually, the trainers at these sessions are highly experienced. In the past, some of these conferences have also offered the opportunity to observe highly experienced teachers teaching actual kids. There is usually a keynote as well as a variety of sessions presented by many different teachers. The other really key part of this kind of conference is the Skills Lab and the coaches who work with different groups on different skills, both in their individual tracks as well as in an open Skills Lab. In my opinion, Skills Labs are where the magic really happens, and this makes these conferences really special. Plus there's usually some social activities (Karaoke, open mic, that sort of thing) to create community and connections. 

Pros: 

    • Being grouped with similarly-experienced teachers is really powerful because the presenters/trainers can tailor content to different levels of understanding. Bonus: you can find like minded teachers with whom to keep learning! (See below!) 
    • Skills labs and coaches: There is something about being in a skills lab- whether you participate as a teacher, student, or observer, that will have a profound effect on your teaching. Being part of the Coaching team is one of the professional achievements that I am most proud of because it is transformative for teachers.  
    • Ideally, each track will have a leader who understands the experience level, the types of roadblocks that are likely to come up based on that experience, and a plan to help everyone through those blocks. 
    • Usually the trainers for the different tracks are highly experienced. 
    • Opportunities to be a language learner (and sometimes observer of students in a classroom). 
Cons
    • Depending on your track (and the conference), the training can be sequenced and intentional, or scattered and piecemeal. It really depends on a lot of different factors.
    • The sessions outside of the tracked plan can be hit or miss. Because they are all individually created, there is no overarching plan and you might hear some people say things that are the opposite of what someone else said, and that can be confusing and frustrating. 
    • Mix of experienced and inexperienced presenters. 

Acquisition Driven Conference

Examples: Comprehensible Iowa, Mitten CI, Comprehensible Midwest, CI Reboot (virtual), Express Fluency's Conference in the Cloud (virtual), The Agen Workshop (France), TCI China (China)

This conference is likely to have some key features: a keynote, some well-known presenters, and lots of sessions on lots of different topics. Sessions tend to be shorter (1 hour, 90 minutes). There may be opportunities to be a language learner in a new-to-you language, and their may be skills labs for you to join in. 

Pros: 
    • These are often regional, so they are easier to get to (depending on if one is in your region or not)
    • You might meet people in your region with whom to keep collaborating! (See below)  
    • Often lower cost.
    • Variety, variety, variety! There will be a lot of different sessions on different topics! And lots of different presenters! 
    • There might be skills labs (Agen) and opportunities to be language learners (also Agen!) 
Cons
    • If you are new to acquisition driven instruction, it can be very overwhelming to attend lots of different sessions.
    • There is no sequence of learning- so you might learn about a skill in one session, and a technique in another, and assessment in another, but not have any idea how to put it all together. 
    • Mix of experienced and inexperienced presenters; sessions can be hit or miss. 
    • Variety of opinions can lead to confusion and overload. 

What conference should I choose? 

Since your time and money are precious, it makes sense to be very thoughtful before committing your money (or your school's money).

Here are are some scenarios and suggestions:
  • I am looking to dip my toes in to acquisition driven instruction and get a lot of different ideas and strategies. I just want some professional development to keep me from getting in a rut. 
    • You might want to look at an Acquisition Driven conference that has or doesn't have tracks.
  • I am new to this whole Acquisition Driven instruction thing and I really want to learn how to do it. 
    • Consider a workshop to take advantage of highly experienced presenters and a sequenced series of learnings.  If none of those work for you, the next option would be a tracked conference. 
  • I feel like I have the basics; I want to go further. 
    • This is where a tracked conference with skills labs really shines! You can take a new language, participate in skills labs, and meet other teachers with similar levels of experience. 
    • Don't discount the power of an expert-led workshop. Skilled trainers are often teaching on multiple levels, and the most experienced ADI teachers know that they can get a lot out of very beginner training (see below). 
  • I am very experienced. But I still want more training.
    • Tracked conferences are great if they have an experienced track or some kind of "teach the teacher" track.
    • Anything that has a skills lab with coaches will be very, very good for you! (Trust me!) 
    • Acquisition Driven conferences can be very good for highly experienced teachers. The variety means you can get what you want, and you probably gravitate toward presenters that you click with. One thing that worked very well for me at these conferences was to go with one theme in mind and attend sessions on that theme, e.g. assessment, reading instruction, upper levels, etc. 

Speaking of folks who are experienced and have a lot of training? 

 It is super common for people who are enthusiastic about teaching with acquisition-driven instruction to poo-poo beginner training. I know I did. I wanted the advanced stuff- badly. I talk to teachers all the time who want "advanced" training. And while I absolutely think there is a place for leveled training experiences, I have come to believe what all the most experienced ADI teacher trainers and coaches kept telling me: you can never work enough on the most basic skills, and you can't be reminded of them enough. AND...

Here's the tricky part (and one possible solution)- although I truly believe that all teachers interested in comprehension based communicative language teaching (aka acquisition driven instruction, comprehensible input) benefit from a back to basics approach, it can be extremely frustrating to be in trainings where the same questions are asked over and over again, and there are no opportunities to dive into what you really need.  

My solution for the very experienced: 

1) Go to all the trainings you can- beginner, advanced, whatever. Do not poo-poo beginner training.

2) Any time you can get into a Skills Lab with a coach...do it.  

3) Find or create a professional learning community (PLC) of teachers with similar training (hint- look for them at conferences!) and process what you learned with them, through your more experienced teacher lens. 

4) Set up a time to meet with them regularly- zoom, google meets, at the local library, etc. One year, my little PLC couldn't find a time to meet so we used the Marco Polo app to leave each other asynchronous messages. 

I hope to see you all at some upcoming conferences and workshops this year! 

If you are the organizer of a conference and you feel like I am representing your work unfairly, please get in touch and we can have a conversation about it, ok? My goal is just to share my own opinions. 


Wednesday, August 18, 2021

Becoming, always becoming, a MORE Equitable Educator: Reflections on my learning

Image of a woman with a handbag on a purple background.
 Text reads: MIT Teaching Systems lab Becoming a more equitable educator.


ABOUT THE COURSE AND MY ROLE

In my role as a community teaching assistant for the MIT Teaching Systems Lab course Becoming a More Equitable Educator, I have learned a lot, interacted with a great variety of educators, and written more than I could have ever imagined.

However, my learning, both from being a student in this course and from participating as a teaching assistant, has been wide ranging and also very action oriented. This is the place for me to talk about what I've done with some of that learning.

USING COMMUNITY ASSETS


image of a two people chatting on a computer and table. 
Text reads: Using community assets. Who are the experts in my community? 
What assets do I have?
During the course, educators are asked to develop a map of community assets. I did not realize that this asset map would serve as a foundation for a great deal of the work that I would do for this past year. I found allies and tapped into an amazing community of educators who had a lot to share about their own work in becoming more equitable.

I felt empowered- because of a new job and a strong sense of wanting to do something- to bring some educators together and create some trainings and resources to address equity in my teaching community. 

Here are some of those trainings and discussions:


Staying true to yourself (with Elicia Cárdenas)

This is equity related, just not directly. It is about making principled choices in teaching, albeit in a very specific context of comprehension based communicative language teaching. The more I explore this topic, the more I am sure that this is about equity.

A conversation on equity and engagement: what does it look like in 2020
with Bob Patrick, Meredith White, John Bracey, Dahiana Castro, and Elicia Cárdenas

EXAMINING OUR STATUS QUO

image: stack of books. Text reads: examining our status quo. 
What are commonly accepted practices that no longer fit with my goals of becoming more equitable? 

There are a lot of commonly accepted practices in world language classes, especially around assessment, that I felt like I needed to really dig into and ask if they were practices that were in line with my goals of becoming more equitable. It turns out that I had a lot to say about engagement, grading accuracy, participation, and more. I *still* have more to say, so when I write more, I will add it.

Addresses equity in our choice of pedagogy 

Things to Avoid: Grading Accuracy, Participation, and Engagement/Effort

UNDERSTANDING THE ROLE OF SELF CARE IN EQUITY WORK

image of a woman with a large heart. Text reads: Understanding the role of self care. 
How does taking care of myself help me be more equitable?
 

This idea has been slowly coalescing and is still in its infancy. It started with a truly transformative experience at the People of Color Conference in a session about the trauma of equity work. I realized that I was carrying around a great deal of trauma from my experiences in working as part of an Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion team. Like- A LOT. While that workshop was specifically focused on healing from trauma, it made me start to wonder:

How can taking care of myself and putting myself first help me be a more equitable educator? Here's what I came up with:

I can be my best self, more often.

If I am well rested and not stressed, I am less likely to react, and more likely to either notice a situation that is going off the rails before it happens or respond in a way that is kind and patient. Hangry me just snaps, gets annoyed, and kicks kids out or shamed them (we have all done it, and I am not proud of it). 

When I show up with my best self, I am much more likely to have an equity mindset. I am more likely to look at any student in any given moment with an asset based and context centered mindset.  

I can focus on what is important, more often. 

If I am taking care of myself and not spending every extra minute doing things that I hate (e.g. grading for the sake of grading, marking errors, etc.), I might also be taking more time to plan better lessons, to create time in my lessons to check in with students, creating or finding better resources, or (gasp) even connecting with other teachers to support my practice. 

This has played out for me in some really significant ways: by being more intentional about how I spend my contract hours, by setting clear boundaries with myself and with others (and still keeping my job!), and being intentional about how I spend my time at school, I found that I had a lot more energy to plan better lessons and find amazing resources, with which to plan better lessons. Prioritizing a manageable work-week was a game changer. Also, it made me sleep better, spend more time doing the things I love, which led to less stress and me being my best self.

I have more energy and resiliency.

I have more energy and resiliency to have hard conversations, to take risks as an educator, and to practice being aware (instead of avoidant).  

I started to explore this idea in a handful of earlier blog posts (What Matters Most and Simplify) but the difference between what I wrote then and what I am thinking now is that self care is not just a nice thing to do, it is vital to be able to engage in the day-to-day work of becoming a more equitable educator. 

Image: people dancing with joy. Text reads: I can be my best self, more often. I
 can focus on what is important, more often. I have more energy and resiliency.


CONCLUSION

What a funny thing to write! There is no end. It's not like I have magically reached "equitable". It is a life-long process. I am constantly learning and un-learning. I am exploring the intersection of anti-blackness, fatphobia, and the role of white supremacy in eating disorders and the thin ideal. I am examining my own intersectional identities as a white skinned chicana, as my family digs out evidence of our very near indigenous roots, and looking at my role as a descendent of colonizers and of those who were colonized.  I am grappling with social media activism (and its harm) and growing my own capacity to be a leader. These are not easy things. 

So, no conclusion, sorry! 

(The course from MIT Teaching Systems Lab ends on August 26, 2021.)

Friday, January 10, 2020

Story asking! Video! Friday Afternoon!


So, you remember that Plan B class? They have made big improvements. HUGE, in fact. Not perfect. Far, far from it.  But...they have come a long way. 

So much that I asked a story in class today!!!  Since storyasking is one of my very favorite things to do in class, I was pretty joyful. Since it was the end of the day on a Friday, I was pretty exhausted.  

In fact, I asked the same story with two different sections of my Spanish 1B class of 8th graders.  


Level Up your Learning


 Use this form (and read the article while you are at it) to observe.  (This was a collaboration between Martina Bex and I.)  

Real talk

Please forgive any and all language mistakes- I am human.  And for a minute, I started to ask the story in past tense, then remembered mid-word what class I was in front of. 

Notes: The first THREE minutes are in English! Gasp! I was setting expectations.  That, to me, is a very good use of L1.   Also, for the first couple minutes or so of the actual story, the camera is on its own personal journey of discovery in my classroom.  It decided not to focus on me at all.  Skip to about minute 5 if you feel like you must, but the sound is pretty good in those first couple of minutes.  

You will see me mouth the words "pollo frito" a few times.  I am doing this because we established (ages ago) that when we say it, one kid leads us in his favorite dance. Thus, I use the magic of the fried chicken dance very carefully.  

At about 13:20, a kid starts to have a side conversation and I have to send them out of the room.  (They are going to work on a written assignment.) 


I also did this story with another class, but for now, here is one video. My apologies for not taking the time to add subtitles.  It's Friday night.

Click here if it won't start playing. 





This lesson is the Story asking part, day 2, of SOMOS 1, Unit 10.  Used with permission.  




Resources about story asking:  
Story asking: Summer SOMOS Fun Club Video
Story asking: bit.ly/storyaskingsupports  
Blog post and more info:  https://comprehensibleclassroom.com/2019/07/24/tprs-storyasking-made-simple/

#StoriesConnect Tips
#1-Set expectations
#2 Managing Choral Responses
#3- Teaching how to make suggestions

What is TPRS™?  




Tuesday, February 12, 2019

Standards Based Grading and My Classroom Practice


Grades. Assessment.  The pile of papers staring at me, just waiting for me to put little marks on them, then enter some more marks in the computer, so that kids and parents can ignore, celebrate, or argue  about (with each other or with me, depending on family culture).


Doesn't it just feel overwhelming sometimes?  And I feel like I have a pretty good handle on it!!! (Click here for information about what goes in my gradebook, here for how I grade reading and listening quizzes, and here for how I grade writing.)

I recently attended a 2 day seminar on Standards Based Grading with Rick Wormeli. (It was awesome.)  I am not at all new to his work and ideas, and I have spent time with proficiency based grading (a la Marzano- two full seminars).  I am also enrolled in an edX course (offered by the MIT teaching and learning lab) about Competency Based Grading.  Since the term ends in a few weeks, I am looking at end of term grades, my grading practice, my assessments, and trying to make sense of my new learning.   So, this is more of a personal blog post, with less practicality and more reflection.

 In no particular order, here is my attempt to process what I came away with:

Schools conspire against learning. Yes, well, this is so patently obvious it almost doesn't need commentary.  If I could just teach, and be free of the arbitrary nature of so much of my job, I would be a better teacher and I think the kids would acquire more.


Never sacrifice sound pedagogy because someone above you isn't there yet.
Yes.  Yes. A MILLION TIMES yes.


Sorting or cultivating? Is one better than the other?
Isn't that language super judgmental?
Are we here to sort or cultivate students?  I think I am here to cultivate students. So what am I doing that is sorting? Is sorting a negative word? Thanks to my colleague today who pointed out that it doesn't have to be negative.  When I differentiate, isn't it sorting?

Is it sorting to put a judgement on a product (an assessment, a project)?  Wormeli argues yes.  He argues that judgement does not promote learning.  But that assumes that students have control over their own learning, which is true for learning that involves the explicit system (math, science, other subjects) but not true for the implicit system of language acquisition.

I believe that giving feedback isn't going to affect their acquisition, especially not at the levels I teach (mostly 1 and 2).  Giving feedback on what they can control- that is, behavior that supports language acquisition...well, now we are getting into compliance.  And that is messy.

On another note: if I am teaching to cultivate, what about tracking students?  (My school has two tracks of math and Spanish.)  This brings up a lot of personal stuff for me because my experience with school was terrible and consisted of virtually no differentiation until there were honors classes that I could go into.  (I dropped out of public school and went to college at age 16.)  Now that I teach honors classes, I strongly believe that I am serving the kids better by splitting them up by proficiency, and meeting them where they are at.  But this is a very unpopular view, and I can see why.  I am going to have to put that one aside for now.

Compliance or competency?  MESSY!  
Compliance vs. Competency: It is MESSY.
Some of my peers and trainers argue that we should never grade for compliance (engagement), because that has nothing to do with their competency. And what about neuro-diverse students?   Others say that we should not grade their competency because they have no control over it, but we should grade what they can control (behaviors that support language learning), which is basically compliance.





Assessment is where we live our values. This resource, from the indominable Tina Hargaden, comes at just the right time.  But it brings up some difficult questions for me.  Am I grading too hard? Am I accurately assessing their proficiency levels?  Am I falsely inflating or deflating grades?  How do I know what proficiency levels look like?

Because if I am being honest, according to Tina's rubrics, I grade WAAAY low.  But I am consistent within my department, and within myself.  This is important to acknowledge, and a thought that I come back to again and again.  Scott Benedict's trainings on assessing freewrites helped me solidify this.  For more information, check out his work at Teachforjune.com.


I am already using standards based grades, and I think that my grades finally (mostly) represent what students can do and understand.  Whew. What a relief.  I have worked SO hard on this. And this is the best year so far, in that my students' reported grades really do seem to reflect their proficiency, not their organization or compliance. Sure, I can improve, but I feel like I am on the right track.  Even if I am trying to squeeze into my school's 100 point averaging system.

If I believe that students have no control over the rate at which they acquire language, I should not be grading them. Period. Full stop.  
Ouch.  And yes.  But reporting what they can do is valuable, both for them and for me, and required in the school system.  And I do like to see what they can do, and so do they.

Corollary: If students can't control what they acquire, why am I spending so much time and effort on this assessment stuff?  I mean, weighing the pig more often does not make it fatter.  
Oh wait. Because this is actually part of my job. Hmm.  Refer to my first point.  However, it does give me some peace thinking that my goal to load up the input, create a community where students feel valued, recognized, and successful, and where I love to go every day (because I have the time for self-care and self-reflection), is actually where my time should be spent.  And the majority of my assessments *should* be input-focused.  (Thanks to Lance Piantaginni for helping me see the value in input-based assessments.  After all: more input is always a good thing.)

I am so grateful to not be tied to a fixed schedule of summative assessments that are worth a certain percent and are unrecoverable.  However, I *am* still tied to getting enough grades in the grade book.  And "citizenship" as a grading category. (Can you hear the scorn dripping from my voice? This is one school requirement that really chafes at me.)




The assumption that students can control their language acquisition is incorrect, and the assumption that giving them descriptive feedback will help is just plain wrong.  Sorry, Rick.  
It might not be wrong for subjects like math etc. that rely on explicit learning, but the nature of second language acquisition is different.  Thanks, Bill VanPatten, for helping me get real clear about this.  So I am not going to spend a ton of time giving them feedback.  The payoff isn't that great for the time spent, especially when I could spend my time taking care of myself so I can better connect with kids, or finding interesting, compelling things to talk about with them, or trying to build my skills to speak so that they understand me.  Because those actions actually will help them acquire more.

Which leads me to some classroom practices that I am re-examining: 




Student Learning Objectives: 

Oh man, we love our objectives, don't we?  Many teachers have to have different ones daily, and track each student through each one and blah blah blah.  I am (once again) very grateful to work at a school where they are not required.  I developed them anyway, and every time I go back to teach a unit again, I look at them to decide if they still have meaning.  I think it is important that the kids know what the end goal is, even if it is very broad.  In fact, I hand them out to the kids to glue in their interactive-ish notebooks, and even post them as part of our starters.


In the first few weeks of the year, I ask students to self-reflect on their learning daily, usually based on the starter we did, and discuss what objective it was checking and what they can do to acquire.


But I stopped doing this around around October. I stopped because I would rather speak Spanish and ask how they are doing and just converse, not meta-process something over which they have no control.  Plus, twice a week, my starter is FVR/SSR, with no paperwork for the kids.




Another reason I stopped going over objectives was because the answer to "how will you move up the proficiency ladder" is ALWAYS more input.  I can remind kids of where to find that input (in class, on my class web page, during office hours, etc.) and that they can access it without anyone else, but the answer never changes.  And I felt like a broken record.  (There might be value in that though.)  It can be useful to have the discussion about the value of "practice", quizlet, and "write sentences". (That is, if it is input, it's great.  "Practicing sentences" or flashcards on quizlet , probably not.)


What I changed: After returning from the Wormeli workshop, I intentionally decided to refer to the objectives again in each class, and give the opportunity for self-reflection of progress.  My high-anxiety, high achievers really liked it.  Most of the others seemed to be confused and/or tuned out. And it took SO MUCH TIME!!

My verdict?  I think that I will continue creating and sharing objectives, and when the mood strikes, ask the kids to look at their progress and the objectives (through the starter), but it is not going to be a daily thing.  Maybe weekly?

Target structures, rubrics, and feedback:
I often ask students to write quick freewrites (10 minutes) at the end of the unit and incorporate the target structures from that unit. For first year students in 7th grade and Spanish 1B (8th grade) I decided that students being able to use the structures as practiced (3rd person) was proficient, as that was mostly what they were reading in the units, and seemed reasonable.  The application of using different endings to the words to talk about self and others seemed like an advanced goal, for writing. So that was my rubric.  I also graded more holistically on a modified ACTFL rubric (basically this from Martina.)   

Now, I have been using this target structures rubric for four years, and never loved it.  What if they use two correctly and forget the third?  Wormeli would perhaps say that I should disaggregate the grade for each in the gradebook to give a better reflection of their learning.  Well, that is great if you are working on different skills in a different subject,  but since I know that language is acquired in messy chunks, and the stages of development are fixed and also messy, and that kind of feedback won't help with acquisition, disaggregating seems like a poor use of (my) limited time.

 Wormeli says that descriptive feedback is helpful. I am doubtful about this assertion regarding language acquisition, but I do see the value in showing students where they did or didn't meet the expectation.

What I changed: I decided to ask the kids.  I took 10 minutes of class and just told them what I was thinking, and asked if the target structures rubric was helpful for them.  They said that they wanted to know which words they were using at what level.  I suggested that I just give them feedback- a checklist and grade them holistically on the ACTFL rubric.
This is the new rubric- this DOES NOT go in the grade book!


It was so smooth for me to grade in this last round of writing, and they commented how useful it was to see what they were doing right.  So that's a keeper!!!

Proficiency levels
Posters on my classroom wall
The last thing that I decided to change up this week was to spend a little bit more time in L1 talking about proficiency levels.

I spend almost a whole day at the beginning of the year having students work on an activity that introduces them to proficiency levels. (See examples below.)  I will write about what I do more specifically- I even have a video- but for now, suffice it to say that I explicitly teach about the ACTFL levels at the beginning of the year, and discuss with kids and families what their goals are (for June).

I also use rubrics with proficiency levels on them already, and I do talk to the students about what they mean.  But am I doing it enough?  This is what I wanted to find out.


Proficiency Project in the hall
I do this at the beginning of the year
(Novice High)
Novice Low
Intermediate  Mid



I decided that after giving a writing quiz, I would take the kids out to the hallway where I have their proficiency level projects hanging.  I asked them to re-read their quizzes and mark on the rubric where they thought they were, proficiency-wise, based on the rubric and the examples we did at the beginning of the year.


Like this adorable cat that doesn't quite fit into his box, kids taught in comprehension based communicative
classrooms don't fit nicely into ACTFL levels.

Now, there is a MAJOR problem with this.  If you have been focused on providing compelling, comprehended input in your classes, you can probably guess what it is.  ACTFL proficiency levels, originally developed for a non-educational context, don't play nicely with kids who get tons of input and start writing paragraphs almost immediately.  They tend to skip novice low completely and speed through novice mid, at least in my experience and understanding.   Depending on the teacher, they might start writing paragraphs in a variety of time frames.
Yes, it is usually messy, but as Tina Hargaden reminds us, novice and intermediate writers need a sympathetic reader.  (And remember, there is no such thing as an error, only an indicator of the developmental stage the learner is in. Again, thanks to BVP for reminding me of this.) So is their writing indicative of micro-fluency, and thus they are really not intermediate low or mid?  Tina has a strong case for the opposite- that teachers constantly rate their students too low.  I am still really struggling with this, and have been for years.

That being said, is this a worthy struggle for me as a teacher?  Does it *really* matter if my kids are novice high or intermediate mid? It is probably not going to change what I do.  I am still going to give them a huge diet of comprehensible, comprehended input, including fiction, non-fiction, academic language, adapted authentic resources, music, etc.

I mean, common language is great but totally meaningless if other teachers have different interpretations of these same words.


Wednesday, August 1, 2018

How to ask a story: Live (facebook live) event: Friday, Aug. 3, 3:30 MST




Hi, this is just a quick announcement to say that if you are part of the SOMOS Facebook group, you can watch a live presentation about how to ask a story using a script from the SOMOS curriculum.


If you are not part of the SOMOS group but want to join, please search for SOMOS in the search function for Facebook and answer the questions so we know you are a real teacher.

This live recording will be available for you to read after the event.

I hope to interact with you there!

Saturday, August 19, 2017

Guatemala: La Escuela de la Montaña


Disclaimer: this post is not about TPRS.  It may come up as it usually does, but if you are reading because you want to know about TPRS, this may not be the most relevant.

This post is about a small language school in rural Guatemala, what life is like there, my experiences there as a student and student coordinator, and why this place is so important in my life.

La Escuela de la Montaña is a small language school that is a project of a larger school, PLQE (Proyecto Lingüístico Quetzalteco), in Quetzaltenango (Xela), located in the Western Highlands of Guatemala.  The school is located about two hours away from Xela, and about 10 kilometers from a small town called Columba.

There are so many things to say about this place that it is difficult to know where to start.

School and Community
The language school is an integral part of the community.  Both communities are groups of former coffee finca (plantation) workers who organized (and suffered) after violations of human and worker's rights.  With support from PLQE and the Catholic church, both communities were able to leave the finca and start over again on their own land.

La Escuela provides work for many women in the two main communities (Fátima and Nuevo San José), where there are few opportunities for anyone in the family to earn a living.  The majority of the men in the area are day laborers, and have to travel 2-3 hours a day (and pay for transport) in the hope of getting a day's wages.  The work for the women is primarily cleaning the school in rotation and cooking for students.  (More about that later.)

The school has created a well-used community library staffed by a teacher for all ages to read and learn.  Most households do not have books, so this is an invaluable resource for the kids and adults.

There is also an arts program that is free for anyone during the school year, adults included, that provides some music and visual art teachers on Saturdays.

http://escuelamontana.org/our-projects/becas/103.html
Scholarships
In addition, there is a very strong scholarship program that serves all the surrounding communities.  In Guatemala, public education is free until the end of 6th grade.  After that, families need to pay tuition, supplies, uniforms, and transportation costs.  There are four more years of education available for those who can pay.  The nearest schools that provide these levels (called Básico and Diversificado) are 1-2 hours away by pickup truck, bus, or microbus.  As such, an education is beyond the reach of many people in the campos.

 La Escuela administrates a scholarship program that  is truly amazing.  Scholarship recipients participate in community service, classes on budgeting, health and adolescence, politics, government, and more.  They have to keep their grades up and attend school regularly, and participate actively in their communities.

I had the great fortune to attend one of the classes on health and puberty and was blown away by the number of kids who were receiving these funds.  It is truly a program that can change the world.

Life for students attending La Escuela
Here is a review I wrote for goverseas.com

Cement block house in Fátima
Let me get a bit of terminology out of the way before I explain a little bit about living in these communities.  Think of a city block.  That is about the size of Fátima.  Nuevo San José is about three blocks in total.  There are a couple of little stores (tiendas), a church, a local primary school, a health house (now mostly defunct due to lack of funding), and a bakery.  Down the road is a larger community with a few more services.  Most houses have some form of electricity, but some don't.  Many have dirt floors and most women still cook off of wood burning stoves.  Many men in the community have traveled north to the USA and send money home, so some homes have more resources than others.  Sinks (pilas) are outside.  Many showers are cold, hooked up to the sinks, and are outside.

It is important to me that readers do not think "How awful" or something like that.  It is easy to be shocked by the poverty and developing country living conditions.  (Also, if you think that only happens in developing countries, I suggest heading to inner-city Baltimore or the Navajo Reservation.) This is just the reality.

Students at La Escuela do not live with families.  They live in relative comfort in a former coffee finca house, in dorm rooms, with relatively hot showers, potable water, indoor plumbing, a kitchen, and usually, electricity.  Also, fresh organic french-press coffee.

Maíz

For meals, you walk down to Nuevo San José or Fátima. The cobbled road is usually slick with rain, moss, and cow dung (a local herd gets walked up and down the road daily).  Students eat three meals a day with a different family each week.  Meals are usually simple- beans, pasta, eggs, some vegetables (which are only sold from a cart on Thursdays, or in Columba), and mountains of home made corn tortillas.  Many families grow their own corn and beans, and late July/August is when they start harvesting.
Reading to kids



Students are encouraged to bring books from the school's library to read to the kids in the family, or art kits that can be checked out.

Classes and Activities
A ranchito
Students take classes either in the mornings or in the afternoons, for four hours a day.  Classes are taught one-on-one by an incredibly talented group of professional language teachers. You meet with your teacher in a little ranchito (a little covered area with a table and whiteboard) outside.  The teachers are passionate, committed, and very good at their work.

Each week, there are a handful of speakers who come to the school to educate students about the political realities of Guatemala.  In the two weeks I was there this time, I got to translate the story of one community's fight for unpaid back wages, that included threats, starvation, and more.  Another community leader came to tell the story of how his community decided, after a lot of injustice and no support from the legal system, to occupy a finca, and how they are working now to transform it into an organic coffee and banana cooperative with community programs to empower women and youth.  In the past, I have translated the story of a torture survivor (during the internal armed conflict), an ex-guerrilla fighter, and others.

There are also community members from Nuevo San José and Fátima that come to discuss their own lives and specialties.  This year, I worked to translate the story of the local midwife, a current-events discussion that focused on corruption in the health system, and a lecture from a local herbal expert who received medical training to help his community use plants and local resources to maintain their health.

In addition, there are soccer games in nearby Columba, hikes to see (or not, depending on the weather) the local active volcano, weekly cooking classes, and more.

Coordinadora
I was invited to work as the fill in coordinator during the time I was there as the full-time coordinator had to return to the States for a couple of weeks.  My role was to translate, support the students as needed, and bridge the gap between the incredible school staff and faculty and the students, some of whom did not speak any Spanish (yet).

It was a lot of work but very fulfilling and kept me busy.  I also attended class each day with the intention of figuring out how to do a TPRS training in Spanish.  (There! I knew I would work TPRS in somehow!)
3 Hypotheses (with spelling errors) about language acquisition
 I was incredibly gratified to learn that the teachers at the school were starving for training, and we had an amazing time working together to help me explain clearly what TPRS is all about for them.  I got to do a demo class with the Spanish students, then a brief demo and explanation with the teachers.  I plan on returning to do a more complete training next summer.

This school is a very special place.  People who end up there tend to be people who are interested in social justice, worker's rights, and human rights.  They tend to be ok with not having internet for a few weeks, and they are usually motivated, compassionate, and interesting.  So that is great too- I get to hang out with interesting people.


Anny, a teacher, and her student, an organizer for worker's rights in Los Angeles,
 doing a brain break with me during class time

Living in Guatemala is not easy.  Transportation is uncomfortable and unreliable.  (Think of a school bus that seats 6-8 adults across, or the back of a pick up truck that is standing room only.)  You can't drink the water and you have to be careful about food.  During the rainy season, nothing dries, and the bugs are out to get you.  And yet, I will continue to back again and again, because it is important, and because I love it there.  
One night, I brought paper and colored pencils to dinner and colored with the kids.
This guy and I clearly have a lot in common!  This is why I come here.
Please get in touch if you would like more information about the school.  I would be happy to answer specific questions or support you if you are interested in going.